#1Free consultation
The Tutoring Underground
Staten Island SHSAT, ISEE, TACHS and SAT/ACT tutoring for grades 3–12
No reviews yetContact for rates📍 Staten Island · 1.4 mi
Best Math Tutors in Staten Island, NY
Elementary arithmetic through pre-calculus, including homework help and skill remediation. Tutors serving Staten Island and NYC Public Schools (Community School District 31).
Last updated
Quick answer
As of November 2026, the top-rated math tutors in Staten Island, NY are The Tutoring Underground (Staten Island, Contact for rates); Huntington Learning Center – Staten Island (Staten Island, Contact for rates); and Caddell Prep (Staten Island, Contact for rates). Rankings are based on review quality, credentials, background checks and responsiveness; sponsored placements are labeled and do not affect rank.
#2
Huntington Learning Center – Staten Island
Tutoring and test-prep center on Richmond Avenue
No reviews yetContact for rates📍 Staten Island · 4.2 mi
#3
Caddell Prep
SAT, SHSAT, TACHS and Regents prep near the Oakwood train station
No reviews yetContact for rates📍 Staten Island · 4.4 mi
| Rank | Tutor | Area | Rating | Rate | Formats |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Tutoring Underground | Staten Island | — | Contact for rates | small-group |
| 2 | Huntington Learning Center – Staten Island | Staten Island | — | Contact for rates | in-person |
| 3 | Caddell Prep | Staten Island | — | Contact for rates | in-person, small-group, online |
See all math tutors in New York or all tutors in Staten Island.
Not sure who to pick?
Tell us your student's subject, grade and schedule. We'll send you up to 3 hand-picked local tutors, free.
Get matched in 2 minutes